When a Subpoena Hits Your Desk: A 5-Step Action Plan for In-House Counsel

October 14, 2026

subpoena, legal action action concept

Whether you are in-house counsel at a large or small company, here’s a number that might get your attention: US subpoena volumes have just hit a seven-year high after years of steady annual increases, according to data from Wolters Kluwer Financial & Corporate Compliance. This research demonstrates just how common subpoenas have become.  So, when a subpoena to your organization comes across your desk, what steps should you take?

First, identify the type of proceeding. While many subpoenas stem from private civil lawsuits, a subpoena issued by a government agency, regulatory body, or grand jury could carry drastically different stakes.

1. Don’t ignore it

Most importantly, don’t ignore the subpoena and don’t delay handling. You have a legal obligation to address it, and ignoring it will not make it go away and may cause more expense.  Read through the document and determine which court or governing authority issued it. If possible, send the subpoena along with all attachments, enclosures, cover letters, and any other accompanying documents to outside counsel. The timing of when you received the subpoena matters and may impact your response deadline, so it is important to give your counsel as much information and lead time as possible.

From the moment you learn of the subpoena, your immediate priority should be to ensure potentially relevant data is preserved and not destroyed.

2. Know your deadlines

Different jurisdictions have different compliance deadlines. Some of these deadlines for things like written objections are sooner than you might think (as quick as ten days in some places).  When paired with the fact that often a subpoena takes a few days to make its way to your desk, you may be under a bigger time crunch than you would like. This is why it is even more important to get your counsel involved right from the start—often they can negotiate an extension to respond to the subpoena, if needed.

Whatever your deadline is, be sure to calendar it right away. And if you plan to move to quash, be aware that the deadline for doing so in some courts is “promptly.”  This is a vague deadline, which makes it even more important that you are moving forward with diligence, as you do not want your organization to be the subject of a decision analyzing whether your delay in moving to quash constituted “promptly” moving.

Check whether testimony is required: Determine whether the subpoena demands documents, testimony, or both. If it includes a request for corporate testimony (such as a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition), your action plan must include identifying and preparing the proper corporate representative. Deposition subpoenas require immediate attention to negotiate topics, set realistic dates, and prevent unreasonable burdens on your personnel.

3. Know that you have options

A subpoena does not automatically require you to hand over every document requested.  Subpoenas may ask you for documents your organization simply does not have, or that would be time-consuming, costly, and burdensome to provide. You are not without recourse. Some options include:

  • Your counsel can negotiate with the issuing counsel regarding the scope of the subpoena and try to come to a deal to produce a narrower subset of records. Often, spending the time to have a discussion between counsel can clarify what the issuing counsel actually wants, and work to allow the parties to find some common ground so you can efficiently provide a response that might be more narrowly tailored than the original requests. A court will also expect you to attempt to work out an agreement before running to the court about the subpoena anyhow, so this is an important step that should not be overlooked.
  • You can serve written objections and explain in those objections why providing responses to certain requests would be problematic, burdensome, expensive, or bring in large volumes of irrelevant information, among other things.
  • You can move to quash or modify the subpoena. This is a formal motion to the court seeking to eliminate or limit certain requests in the subpoena. Make sure you are mindful of what court you are in and your deadlines to move to quash, as well as any pre-motion conferral requirements that may apply in the applicable jurisdiction as you consider this option.
  • You may be able to seek costs. Certain courts such as federal courts protect subpoenaed non-parties from “significant expense” in responding to subpoenas.  New York and New Jersey’s courts have similar protections. However, be aware of the rule in your jurisdiction, as some courts find that if you voluntarily comply before being ordered to, you have forfeited your right to reimbursement.
  • To be well-positioned for seeking your costs, be sure to raise the issue with issuing counsel during a conferral, and before incurring costs, explain expected costs to the other side. If they have issued unreasonably broad demands and you have warned them of the costs to comply, yet they still refuse to narrow their demands, they cannot act surprised when they are asked to pay for your costs of compliance and the court will certainly be more inclined to consider your request. Be sure you are keeping good documentation of your costs incurred, as you may have to make a formal motion seeking these costs.
4. Preserve formally, produce thoughtfully

Legal preservation begins the moment the subpoena arrives. Immediately issue a formal written litigation hold to your IT department to suspend all automatic deletion, auto-archiving, or backup rotation policies. Concurrently, distribute the hold notice to individual custodians and departments likely to possess relevant records.

Once data is locked down, proceed thoughtfully with the review and production process:

  • Cull internally first: Establish good internal filtering and organizational processes to weed out obviously non-responsive data before sending files to outside counsel. This reduces attorney review time and could lower overall legal costs. Be sure to document the process that you followed so outside counsel can defend or modify it, as necessary.
  • Review for privilege and confidentiality: Ensure all documents are reviewed for attorney-client privilege, work product, trade secrets, and protected data, including  Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and Personally Identifiable Information (PII) compliance.
  • Address partner and vendor restrictions: Check contracts with suppliers, clients, or business partners for any confidentiality or advance notice obligations required before disclosing shared records. If sensitive information must be produced, negotiate an appropriate protective order with issuing counsel prior to disclosure.
5. Institutionalize your action plan for next time

The best time to prepare your plan for responding to a subpoena is before you receive one.  Consider who the point person (or department) at your organization is who will be responsible for intake of the subpoena and assigning outside counsel. Prepare (and regularly revisit and update) a form litigation hold that you can update as needed for each subpoena. Know who your go-to outside counsel will be—it is far better to choose a firm you like that understands your business and can be at the ready before you have deadlines. You don’t want to be scrambling to choose one at the eleventh hour. Consider whether your records management systems are organized and searchable. If not, work on improving your systems.

Conclusion

A subpoena does not have to derail your organization. With a thoughtful approach and the right preparation, it is entirely manageable. Act prudently, read carefully, preserve immediately, and know you have options. An organized company has far more control over a subpoena process than one might think, and those who have a plan in place are best positioned to handle a subpoena in a way that both complies with legal obligations and minimizes organizational disruption.

  • Margaret Raymond-Flood, Today's General Counsel, Columnist

    Margaret Raymond-Flood is a member of Norris McLaughlin, P.A. where she is on the firm’s Management Committee and Co-Chair of the Litigation Practice Group. She devotes her practice to general litigation with an emphasis on complex commercial matters representing large and mid-size institutional clients. She can be reached at mraymondflood@norris-law.com.

  • Kim Weber, Today's General Counsel, Columnist

    Kimbrilee M. Weber is a member at Norris McLaughlin, P.A. and focuses her practice on complex commercial litigation matters, as well as privacy matters involving data protection and compliance.  She regularly represents clients in a variety of high-stakes litigation in state and federal courts in New York and New Jersey. She can be reached at kmweber@norris-law.com.

Must read intelligence for general counsel

Subscribe to the Daily Updates newsletter to be at the forefront of best practices and the latest legal news.

Daily Updates

Sign up for our free daily newsletter for the latest news and business legal developments.

Test your knowledge with our monthly legal crossword puzzle.

Scroll to Top