US and Canadian Courts Raise the Bar on Securities Class Certification

October 13, 2026

US and Canadian Courts Raise the Bar on Securities Class Certification

A recent US appellate ruling involving The Boeing Company reinforces the theory that courts must scrutinize proposed damages calculations before allowing a securities class action to proceed.

Canadian firm Blakes writes that this ruling echoes how courts approach similar gatekeeping questions in Canada. Both systems are agreeing that plaintiffs cannot rely on vague loss theories to unlock class treatment.

In the Boeing matter, investors alleged the company inflated share prices by misleading the market about its safety practices following two incidents involving its 737 MAX. Seeking certification, they offered a generic damages model rather than a specific, evidence-backed method for calculating the alleged inflation.

The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit unanimously rejected certification, applying the standard from Comcast Corp. v. Behrend, holding that plaintiffs must tie damages to their liability theory and support it with real evidence.

The article compares this to Canada, where secondary market securities claims face two hurdles: certification and a separate leave requirement. Canadian certification demands a credible damages methodology, though the bar is lower than in the US.

Leave is more demanding still, requiring plausible legal analysis and credible evidence, a standard the Court called stricter than certification.

Recent decisions, including the Supreme Court of British Columbia’s denial of leave in Larouche v. PGM ResidualCo Holdings Inc., show Canadian courts applying this scrutiny in practice.

For legal teams, this signals an enforcement trend favoring earlier review of damages theories rather than deferring scrutiny to trial. Lawyers handling related proceedings should note the jurisdictional risk from differing evidentiary thresholds.

Disclosure obligations remain central, since both frameworks hinge on whether alleged misstatements can be linked to price movement.

Is your company ready for a class action? Read this article to find out. 

Critical intelligence for general counsel

Stay on top of the latest news, solutions and best practices by reading Daily Updates from Today's General Counsel.

Daily Updates

Sign up for our free daily newsletter for the latest news and business legal developments.

Test your knowledge with our monthly legal crossword puzzle.

Scroll to Top